That Desert Island Comics meme that's hit the blogosphere has been running through my (large, kind of lumpy) head for the last few days and I've finally decided upon the five comics runs I would want to take with me if I were placed on a desert island with, presumably, enough water and food to make life worthwhile, otherwise I'd be asking for
Basic Protein and Hydration Funnies.
Without hesitation, the first material placed in the giant trunk would be Jack Kirby's
Fourth World. I'll claim all of the various series, including his
Jimmy Olsen run and
The Hunger Dogs under a "one cohesive universe created by The King" clause that you can't question; there's only around 60 books total in there, anyway. It's Jack's apotheosis: the madness of creations like The Black Racer; the struggle between Orion and his sire, Darkseid; Barda being six shades of hot as Mister Miracle escapes one outrageous trap after another. This is American comics at their purest and most imaginative, even if Carmine Infantino made Curt Swan and Neal Adams redraw Superman's face repeatedly.
Yes, I still have a beef over that.

Speaking of Jack, I could do a lot worse than getting a complete stack of
Fantastic Four issues dropped into the carry-all. When done properly (which is pretty rare, I'll admit), Comics' First Family represent a lot of the reasons that I love a good superhero yarn: they do what they do because they
can. Yes, Ben Grimm gripes and grouses about being stuck in a giant rock body, but he never, ever hesitates to put himself in harm's way. Johnny seems like a stupid, impulsive teenager, but he comes through when he needs to, even if he bitches a lot about having to do so. Then, there's Reed and Sue: where Superman and Lois could never have gotten married during the Silver Age, Reed and Susan Richards represent an equal partnership. It's pretty cliche to say that Reed's the brain of the group while Susan represents the heart, but it's a cliche because true, even if Stan and Jack seemed to go for months without letting Sue do more than pine and pine.
Even with long stretches of mediocrity, there's something about the Fantastic Four that just plain
works for me. Maybe it's because they're happy to be superheroes (even The Thing when he's been taking his Effexor.) Maybe it's the fact that they routinely do the impossible, the cosmic, the (excuse me)
fantastic as if they're going to the bodega around the corner for some ice cream. I don't know, really, but with great runs from Lee and Kirby, John Byrne, and Walt Simonson and a family that I (kind of stupidly) care about, the over-five-hundred issue series has earned its way onto my island.
Note: I would insist that I could bring this random comic along just because it's a fun,stupid story that makes me terribly happy.
Since I'm assuming that I'd never get off this island paradise on which I've found myself deposited, maybe it would be time to finally suss out just what the fuck is going on in large chunks of
The Invisibles. I'm sure I've got most of the basics down, but I think some sunstroke and periods of deep meditation might bring me closer to the truth about this deeply fucked up, brilliant series that I break out every year in a quest to get closer to figuring out
what the fuck was going on in Grant Morrison's brain as he wrote this stuff. Time travel, alternate dimensions, global conspiracies, and narrative tricks that make you boggle all pile up in the closest thing that DC or Marvel have come to reproducing that dizzying feel that
Ulysses gives everyone who comes within ten feet of it.

Here's where I admit to a grotesque personal failure: I've never read as much
Love And Rockets as I should. Oh, yes, I've read the collections over the last couple of decades and still keep up with the current series, but it's been sort of a long, stretched-out affair featuring gaps with names like
Penny Century and
Luba that requires some quiet time between me and the Brothers Hernandez's work in order to reaffirm our dedication to each other.
See also: the many, many hot women contained within mean that I won't need to find an Eros title to put on this list. 
It's
Watchmen. It'd be like having a Greatest American Films list and not including
Citizen Kane. (Yes, I fucking love
Citizen Kane - the camerawork, the storytelling, the acting, everything is just about as perfect as these things come.) I still find new things in Alan Moore's biggest, most popular work with subsequent readings. It's tough just to pick a single work by Moore out, but this rises just that extra hairsbreadth above the rest to win. (His
Supreme came closest to toppling it, since it's the best Superman run in the last 20 years.)
God, that was fucking hard. I'm sorry there was only five because that means I'd miss out on
Optic Nerve and
DC: The New Frontier and
Nexus and
Concrete and
Stray Bullets and...